Monday, October 05, 2009

Portraits, the Father of the Nation and Intellectual Property [India]

A Division Bench of the Kerala High Court on 1 st October 2009 issued notice to the Union government, MontBlanc International GmbH, Germany, and other respondents on a writ petition that sought a ban on the marketing and sale of “Mahatma Gandhi Limited Edition 241” and “Mahatma Gandhi Limited Edition 3000” luxury pens in the country.

The Bench, comprising Chief Justice S.R. Bannurmath and Justice A.K. Basheer, issued the notice on the petition filed by Dijo Kappen, managing trustee of the Centre for Consumer Education at Pala in Kottayam.

Montblanc International, on September 29, launched a set of high-end pens priced at Rs.14 lakh each under its limited-edition series called the “Mahatma Gandhi Limited Edition-241.” The 241 pens in the series were made to signify the “241 miles” travelled by Gandhiji during the Dandi March.

The petitioner said the attempt by the pen company to market luxury pens in the name of the Mahatma Gandhi was in derogation of national honour. The Father of the Nation was considered the epitome of simplicity and making him the symbol of a pen that cost Rs.14 lakh was nothing but an attempt to degrade everything he stood for, and to mock a nation of middle-class and below-the-poverty-line persons who look up to him and whom he tried to liberate.

Mahatma Gandhi wrote "I have no copyright in my portraits but I am unable to give the consent you require." in May 1931, in response to a manufacturer who wanted to use his portrait in roofing tiles. Nearly four score years on, an international luxury brand wants to do precisely what Gandhi expressly bid against - use his portrait in the manufacture of prohibitively expensive, limited edition pens.
As it has turned out, within days of announcing the launch of Montblanc's limited edition pens commemorating the 140th birth anniversary of MK Gandhi, the German premium pen maker has been issued a notice by the Kerala High Court on a writ petition seeking a ban on the marketing and sale of these pens.

Specifically, the petition draws attention to Section 3 of the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950 (download link), under which "no person shall, except in such cases and under such conditions as may be prescribed by the Central Government, use , or continue to use, for the purpose of any trade, business or calling or profession, or in the title of any patent, or in any trademark or design, any name or emblem specified in the Schedule or any colourable imitation thereof without the previous permission of the Central government".

Further, Entry 9A of the Schedule to the Act lists “the name or pictorial representation of Mahatma Gandhi” as an item that categorically cannot be used for the purpose of any trade, business or profession under the provisions of the Act. The petition argues that "Mahatma Gandhi is considered as the epitome of simplicity"... and "Making him the symbol of a 14 lakh pen is nothing but an attempt to degrade everything that Gandhiji symbolised, and to mock a nation of middle class and individuals below the poverty line who look up to him and who he tried to liberate."
"Gandhi's great-grandson Tushar Gandhi has endorsed the idea. His charitable foundation has already received a donation of $145,000 from Montblanc and will receive between $200 and $1,000 for each pen sold." Tushar Gandhi is reported to have announced at the pen launch that “It’s a pen which Gandhiji always associated with, it was his greatest tool. Also the donation is for an Indian Trust,which is for the good of the Society.”
The petition counters that the Rs 70-lakh donation received by the Kolhapur-based charitable trust, and Tushar Gandhi's subsequent comment is nothing but a "mischievous statement intended to give an impression that the Mahatma used Mont Blanc pens."
Tushar Gandhi seems to the only man standing in the Gandhi family in his endorsement of the brand. In an overnight response to the launch, the Mahatma's governor-grandson, Gopalkrishna Gandhi, has written a moving piece of his grandfather's relationship with the pen and the act of writing. Here, he recalls the story of the tile manufacturer quoted at the top of this note, as also other anecdotes which clearly suggest that Gandhi himself would have objected to the use of his portrait in this manner, were he alive today.
Meanwhile, Montblanc executives appear to be flummoxed: In an interview with the BBC,the company's chief executive Lutz Bethge stated that the pen was intended to honour Gandhi, and he "wouldn't have thought that people would have reacted negatively"

37 comments:

Sneha said...

Dear Mr. Ryder,

I have been following this story on SpicyIP as well and I ask you the same questions I raised there.

As per my understanding, the legal issue in this dispute arises due to the prohibition under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act. Had it not been for the prohibition, then only the Mahatma's unwillingness to give his consent as far back as 1931 for use of his image for commercial gain would be responsible for the ethical dilemma that Mont Blanc has been embroiled in.

The purpose of these special commemorative editions is to honour and celebrate eminent personalities. Assuming that there is no prohibition under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, what would the consequence be if any other eminent personality (lets take an example of Mother Teresa) also refuses such consent?

robenamunroe0513 said...

wonderful..................................................

艾維 said...

小魔女視訊小魔女自拍成人天堂小魔女自拍寫真小魔女自拍天堂成人小魔女自拍天堂小魔女自拍小魔女自天堂小魔女聊天室小魔女網站小魔女的自拍天堂小飄蟲情色論談小陰脣對熟女的性愛方式尋找3p情色故事尋夢圓聊天室免費a片電影免費a片試看免費a片無碼影片免費a片無碼免費影片觀賞免費a片情色卡通免費a片區免費a片看動漫免費a片是看免費a片長片免費a片成人網免費a片下載網址免費a片下載區免費av影片下載免費av影片免費av漫畫要如何看免費a片要看免費a片西洋正妹牆西洋未成年網站介紹西洋成人漫畫西洋愛情小說西洋情寫真西洋情色線上觀看西洋情色網西洋情色西洋美女裸體圖西洋美女短片免費試看褲襪做愛褲襪辣妹褲襪走光

健康保寶 said...

TAHNKS FOR YOUR SHARING~~~VERY NICE ........................................

開心唷 said...

以簡單的行為愉悅他人的心靈,勝過千人低頭禱告........................................

彥羽 said...

嘟嘟貼圖電眼美女jp素人露出大全集人體藝術寫真夜店正妹正妹強正妹報時正妹圖片av999免費影片250av女優免費影片星野亞溪星野亞桌布春天貼圖網春天貼圖情色網春天吶喊比基尼辣妹時尚男女聊天室景美女中前女友自拍景美女中自拍女學生時間停止器短片 線上觀看時間計時器美女 視訊美女 視訊視訊交友fireup日本a片免費下載xx369色女人專用愛愛一葉情貼影色站露點girl532085cc成人片觀看一夜聊天室免費a片77p2p成人文章一葉情貼圖片區影音視訊聊天777美女dvd影片777美女dvd小魔女影城免費成人聊天室免費影音下載hibb美眉共和國美女短片免費試看色美媚部落格

郭美娟 said...

大肚能容,了卻人間多少事,滿腔歡喜,笑開天下古今愁。 ..................................................

婷妏 said...

I love readding, and thanks for your artical...................................................

BertR_Dimarco223965 said...

Nice Post~!!!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

明宏 said...

thanks................................................

CleoL_V said...

您好~~~..............................

Glennie9654 said...

cool blog,期待更新........................................

Fe024lixV_Ferrari1 said...

pleasure to find such a good artical! please keep update!!.............................................

雅鈴 said...

78論壇 A片,成人影片分享 080視訊聊天室 666成人 視訊交友網 xvideo免費影片 視訊美女ws888 6k聊天室辣妹視訊 A片-免費視訊 視訊美女mybank sex888影音視訊聊天室 影音情人趣味 85cc免費影片 視訊激麻館 禁地論壇成人 情色視訊 成人影片情色網 bt成人論壇 18成人avooo 玩美女人試看片 hilive tv視訊妹 免費聊天firework av999免費影片 avdvd無碼影片成人情色 一葉晴貼影片av127 520聊天室 一夜情視訊聊天室 視訊聊天室交友 免費視訊辣妹avdvd一夜情 1元視訊 網愛聊天 250av女優免費影片 免費影音視訊fm358 sex女優王國情色 嘟嘟情人色網 dvd 台灣18網 視訊交友雙贏論壇 色a金激麻館 性愛故事性愛文學 凹凸情欲網 成人視訊happylife 視訊聊天交友mm358 免費視訊辣妹sex女優王國 情色香港論壇 亞洲情色貼圖區 日本 a 片自拍偷拍網站情色小說 免費avi影片下載 台灣情色視訊網 17358 視訊聊天室 日本a片免費下載 情色影片免費觀賞you tube影片下載

熙辰 said...

若無一番寒徹骨,焉得梅花撲鼻香。 ............................................................

D415_evonN_Risinger0 said...

知識可以傳授,智慧卻不行。每個人必須成為他自己。...........................................................................

jackveronic said...

靠山山倒,靠人人老,靠自己最好。 ............................................................

saa said...

nice to know you, and glad to find such a good artical!.........................

瓊富 said...

很喜歡你的部落格 留言支持你 祝你人氣長紅~~~......................................................................

王婷珊 said...

所有的資產,在不被諒解時,都成了負債.................................................................

祐白祐白 said...

在莫非定律中有項笨蛋定律:「一個組織中的笨蛋,恆大於等於三分之二。」....................................................................

靜宸靜宸靜宸 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。.................................................................

吳婷婷 said...

It takes all kinds to make a world.............................................................

PearleY建佑 said...

不只BLOG內容很棒留言也很精采 XDDDD..................................................................

佩璇佩璇 said...

心平氣和~祝你也快樂~~..................................................................

李冠文 said...

hello, i visited~~感謝大大分享..!..................................................................

倫惟倫惟 said...

看後受益良多,謝謝∪ˍ∪......................................................

曾法幸 said...

Say not all that you know, believe not all that you hear.............................................................

溫緯李娟王季 said...

蛛絲馬跡皆學問、落花水面皆文章............................................................

佳瑩佳瑩 said...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。..................................................

王建勳 said...

愛情是一種發明,需要不斷改良。只是,這種發明和其他發明不一樣,它沒有專利權,隨時會被人搶走。.................................................................

李蔡文山家榮 said...

人不可以求其備,必捨其所短,取其所長............................................................

文岳仲君 said...

More haste, less speed..................................................................

凱許倫 said...

Judge not of men and things at first sight................................................

小米 said...

心中醒,口中說,紙上作,不從身上習過,皆無用也。..................................................

文王廷 said...

很棒的分享~祝福你............................................................

承王蓁 said...

很棒的分享~祝福你............................................................