Showing posts with label Patent Office. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Patent Office. Show all posts

Monday, November 24, 2008

Patent officers should coordinate to bring uniformity in standards [India]

Many of India’s pharma companies, including even the big and transnational ones who themselves have some stake in innovation and R&D, are alleging that patent authorities in India have become very liberal when it comes to grant of patents. Many frivolous patents have been granted and even bogus applications are being entertained, they say. The Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance, a group of big India-born drug companies, is mulling a thorough study of the patents granted since 2005 to find out how many of these are in fact ‘bad patents.’ At the other end of the scale, the foreign pharma companies not only brush aside the allegation of granting patents for ‘trivial inventions’ but also aver that “a lot of important applications” have in fact been turned down by India’s patent authorities. The question that underlies this row is what’s a ‘patentable invention’. At a very general and non-codified level, the newness or rather the surprise element of an invention should be the deciding factor.

The World Trade Organisation’s Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement defines the term ‘patentable subject matter’ with due considerations to present-day commercial realities—it says an invention should be “new, involve an inventive step and capable of industrial application” to be deserving of a patent. National governments have drawn a lot of freedom from the TRIPS agreement itself and even autonomously to elaborate on the TRIPS definition. However, national laws of many countries, including the US, are framed in such a way that even “incremental, adaptive or cumulative” inventions could qualify for patents if such invention has a definitive industrial use and thereby considerable commercial value. Indian government has been chary about unfair patenting—thanks to lobbying by domestic industry and the unrelenting stand of leftist outfits. It introduced an additional provision—Section 3(d)—in Patents Act to make patenting criteria more stringent in the pharmaceutical space. This provision was introduced through the third amendment to the Act, which also introduced product patenting for pharma and agrochem inventions.

While the Big Pharma—the large pharmaceutical companies based in the US and EU who hold most of the patents—have been a strident critic of Section 3(d), international organisations like the World Intellectual Property Organisation endorsed it and termed it TRIPS-compliant. According to this provision, incremental inventions (like salts, isomers etc of known molecules) can be patented only if they have contributed to improve the efficacy of the (known) substance. And the patent authorities—read the examiners—would decide if efficacy has really been improved. The current strife over the allegation of the patent authorities practically becoming very liberal in grant of patents would need to be viewed in this context. The fact is India’s Patent Act, even with the fairly elaborate rules notified under it including those to support the Section 3(d), bestows substantial discretionary authority with the patent authorities. Patent examiners in India are still grappling with the complexity of the world of pharmaceutical inventions—the area is abstruse and dynamic enough to baffle even the seasoned examiners. Leaving a lot of things to the discretion of a group of patent examiners is therefore bound to generate conflicts. Here, what the government can do is to create many layers of examiners so that the probability of genuine error can be minimised. But the patent examination, search and grant system in India is currently highly unorganised. The four patent offices—Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai—are yet to achieve a fair degree of cohesiveness among them. These offices, manned by patent controllers and scores of patent examiners who assist them, are allegedly employing separate yardsticks and this is what caused the current allegations and counter-allegations. Clearly, there is a case for a very high degree of coordination between the four patent offices. Patents are anyway prone to contestation. Some disputes would inevitably reach the courts. Such disputes can however be minimised by bringing as much uniformity as possible in standards of patent grant. The Patent Act already provides for pre and post grant opposition and making a review plea before the controller who granted/denied the patent. And there’s the intellectual property appellate board, which is the body for the aggrieved to appeal to. What is lacking is proper coordination among the patent controllers and examiners. The government would do well to address the issue immediately.

Sunday, February 10, 2008

The Patent Pal Toolbar [International]

If you like toolbars, you'll love the free Patent Pal from Jay Wahlquist of Fogg & Powers.
It supports over 20 unique patent related searches, including Google Patents, FreePatentsOnline, Esp@cenet, WIPO, Pat2Pdf, the MPEP, and many more listed on the screenshots page. It also includes links to other useful resources for both US and foreign patent practice, such as links to every major patent office in the world and various ppatent law journals.

New Test for Business Method Patentability Produces Same Results [UKIPO]

The UK Court of Appeal’s recent judgment in the matters of Aerotel Ltd v Telco Holdings Ltd (and others) and Macrossan’s Application [2006] EWCA Civ 1371 ("Aerotel/Macrossan") (236Kb) proposed a new test for assessing whether inventions such as business methods relate to patentable subject matter.
In response to that decision, the UK Intellectual Property Office ("Office") issued an official practice note on the way patent examiners assess whether inventions are for patentable subject matter.
This notice supersedes the following Practice Notices:
Patents Act 1977: Examining for Patentability (29 July 2005)
Handling Patent Applications for Excluded Subject Matter (8 February 2002)
Patents Act 1977: interpreting section 1(2) (24 April 2002)
Claims to Programs for computers (19 April 1999)Other Practice Notices on the question of patentable subject matter still stand save as follows:
Patentability of games (25 November 2005): Paragraph 4 is superseded by the present Notice. The rest of this Notice, which explained the comptroller would no longer rely on the Official Ruling 1926(A), still stands.
Patent applications relating to methods of doing business (24 November 2004): This said the Office would bring appropriate cases to a hearing at an earlier stage and issue abbreviated decisions. This still stands, and indeed may become even more relevant now that Aerotel/Macrossan has simplified the approach.A new assessment by the UKIPO now also gives some examples of how the Office sees the test being applied in practice. The examples chosen are patent applications that were refused by hearing officers earlier this year using the old tests. According to the Office, "In every case the new test appears to come to the same conclusion, thus confirming the Court’s view that the new test is consistent with previous decisions of the Court."

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

'Overhaul India’s patent processes’: Panel’s report to the Prime Minister calls for systemic reform to ensure accessibility and transparency

Acknowledging systemic problems with India’s patent offices, the National Knowledge Commission, under the chairmanship of Sam Pitroda, has called for a complete overhaul in the patent examination system.The commission is a high-level advisory body to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and is charged with transforming India into a knowledge centre.

The commission’s recommendations to Singh, a copy of which has been reviewed, said the patent examination procedures, practices and decisions in patent offices should be streamlined. It also suggested that a new detailed manual for examining patents should be created.

The report was submitted in October, but is only now coming to light. The recommendations were made after consulting industries, lawyers, scientists and technocrats. The commission suggested that patent offices must have adequate technology that will allow for transparent and publicly accessible databases. Recommendations are outlined for 10 key areas that will facilitate a systemic reform.

“The process in intellectual property offices needs to become more accessible and reader-friendly and, therefore, the ultimate objective of all efforts to modernize the patent offices must be to facilitate more transparency and procedural ease for the inventor as well as the common man,” the commission wrote.

The commission recommended that all patent applications be released with complete details so as to give sufficient opportunity for any pre-grant objections. “It is particularly essential to provide electronic access in real time to all steps of a patent application, from the detailed patent description, examination reports at each stage and all amendments introduced at various points, in order to maintain complete transparency,” the report said.

On 31 December, India’s patent offices have been criticized for not releasing enough and timely information about patent applications even as there has been a surge in patents granted. Critics have complained that lack of information prevents them from challenging patent applications.
Indian patent offices publish only abstracts of claims in patent applications, often with a delay of several months before and after they examine such applications.

During 2005-06, the last year for which official data is available, India’s patent grants soared 125% from the previous year. The country’s four patent offices in New Delhi, Kolkata, Mumbai and Chennai collectively granted 4,320 patents during this period even as the number of patent examiners fell to 140 from 196 in the previous year.

Even though the intellectual property offices received some 24,505 patent applications in 2006, there were only 161 oppositions during the year. The number of patent applications abandoned by the department was, however, comparatively lower in 2005-06 than in previous years, according to the 2005-06 annual general report of the controller general of patents, designs and trademarks. Patent offices abandon those applications where there is no merit in the claims.
Other recommendations of the commission include introduction of incentives to attract and retain talent; adequate training and human resource development for patent offices; spreading intellectual property rights education beyond patent offices among scientists and engineers, and establishing an expert institute for patent policy research.

It also called for setting up of a special intellectual property rights tribunal; adequate protection for traditional knowledge; investment in the intellectual needs of small and medium enterprises, and identification of intellectual property issues in fields of emerging technologies.

Tuesday, January 08, 2008

Patent Problems [India]

The country’s intellectual property protection regime has seldom been sans controversy, despite amendment of the Patent Act in 2005 to broadly align it with global norms. The latest salvo has been fired by about 150 patent experts and industry representatives, who have written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and demanded greater transparency and accountability in the granting of patents. A few weeks prior to this, the National Knowledge Commission had submitted a report to the government, pointing out several systemic problems with the patent office and commended an overhaul of patent-granting processes. Indeed, what is striking is that, though the number of applications being filed for patents has spurted several-fold, especially after the amended law came into effect and provided for product patents in addition to process patents, neither the patent office network nor the facilities available there have been adequately augmented. The patent application examiners are clearly not adequate to handle the swollen volume of work. It is no wonder then that the Knowledge Commission’s recommendation for creating an online database, containing complete information on patent applications and grants, copies of patent office decisions, and patent examination details, has not been implemented as yet. Such information is vital for pre-grant challenge. All that is done usually is to publish abstracts of claims which often happen to be the same as given by the patent seekers in their applications. The details of the patent examiners’ reports, indicating the reasons for accepting or turning down a claim, are mostly not disclosed, rendering the system opaque. This obviously leaves little room for public scrutiny, leave alone peer review, of the patent office’s decisions. Consequently, no more than a fraction of the total patent requests get contested at the pre-grant stage.
The disabilities of the patent office aside, the amended legal framework for patents has run into its own problems. The most direct reference to this was made in the report of the technical experts committee on patents, headed by the noted scientist, R A Mashelkar. It categorically stated that limiting the scope of patentability to new chemical entities alone violates Article 27 of the trade related intellectual property rights (TRIPs) agreement of the World Trade Organisation (WTO). Though this report was subsequently withdrawn by the committee following allegations of plagiarism, that does not make a material difference to the issue raised.
Under such circumstances, the scope for misleading the patent office to get frivolous patents or even ever-greening patents through selective information disclosure cannot be ruled out. It is, therefore, important for the patent office to provide electronic access to the proceedings leading to the grant of patent, including examination reports, so as to ensure transparency and fair play. Also needed is expansion in the staff, notably application examiners, and an upgrade of their technical competence through regular training. Such a measure has become all the more critical following the Indian patent office’s recognition by the WTO’s World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO) as the international searching authority and the international preliminary examining authority.

Thursday, December 20, 2007

WIPO grants global search status to India Patent Office

Indian industrial and product innovators will be able to apply for global patents from the home country with World Intellectual Property Organisation granting Indian Patent Office the prestigious status of 'International Searching Authority'.
"The Indian Patent Office has been granted the status of International Searching Authority (ISA) and International Examining Authority a prestigious status given to a few countries," an official said.
India has been given the new status by Geneva-based WIPO after the proposal was cleared by the members of the Patent Committee Union Assembly recently.
As an ISA, major functions of the Indian Patent Office will be to approve or establish the title and conduct international searches.
India has modernised its patent offices using state-of-the-art information technology which has helped cut time in granting patents.