Showing posts with label unregistered marks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unregistered marks. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

ITC, Punchgini and Bukhara: ITC prevails as Second Circuit Court applies Unfair Competition [United States]

In ITC Limited and ITC Hotels Limited v. Punchgini Inc. USCOA 2 No. 165 (N.Y. December 13, 2007), the Second Circuit court refused to apply the doctrine of famous marks to stop the infringement of an Indian trademark ‘Bukhara’. Nevertheless, the New York Court of Appeals applied the law of Unfair Competition to protect the trademark not specifically being used in the US at that point of time. The plaintiff was running a five star restaurant in New Delhi by the name ‘Bukhara’. It had acquired “some measure of reknown among those with an avid interest in fine cuisine.” Later, they decided to open nine restaurants in different parts of the world including US. However, the two Bukhara restaurants opened in US were closed down within a short span. Few former employees of Bukhara of New Delhi opened a Bukhara Grill and Bukhara II restaurants in Manhattan. They used the same logos, style, design, recipes and even the dresses of the waiters of the original Bukhara.

The Second Circuit refused to acknowledge trademark infringement because the plaintiff had abandoned the use of the trademark in the US, though they continued to operate in India.
The New York Court of Appeals later concluded that New York law "recognizes common law unfair competition claims, but not the ‘famous’ or ‘well-known’ marks doctrine."

Unfair Competition law prohibits use of another’s trademark or indication which is identical or similar to other persons goods that are widely recognized among users and thereby causing one's goods or business to be confounded with another person's business. Accordingly, “when a business, through reknown in New York, possesses goodwill constituting property or commercial advantage in this state, that goodwill is protected from misappropriation under New York unfair competition law. This is so whether the business is domestic or foreign.” Further, it was stated that the consumers of services provided by the defendants “must primarily associate the mark with the foreign plaintiff.” The court refused to exhaustively state the factors to determine this, stating that they would “vary with the facts of each case”. However, there has to be “evidence that the defendant intentionally associated its goods with those of the foreign plaintiff in the minds of the public, such as public statements or advertising stating or implying a connection with the foreign plaintiff; direct evidence, such as consumer surveys, indicating that consumers of defendant's goods or services believe them to be associated with the plaintiff; and evidence of actual overlap between customers of the New York defendant and the foreign plaintiff.”

The case is foundational in that it represents a paradigm shift in protection of foreign trademarks in the US. They now qualify for protection even though they may not be registered in the US, the underlying principle being that commercial unfairness should be restrained whenever there is misappropriation, for the benefit of the person who holds a legitimate property right.

Monday, February 11, 2008

Trademark breach: US software co plans action in India

Compuware looking at resolving issue, with a possible legal course against a Mumbai firm with similar name

Nasdaq-listed Compuware Corp., which makes business software and offers IT services, has been operating in India since 2000, and even set up a liaison office here last year. But the company was recently in for a rude shock—it discovered it wasn’t the only Compuware in the country.

The Detroit, Michigan-based firm, which ended the year to March with $1.2 billion (Rs4,716 crore) in revenue, discovered two weeks back that it shares its name with Mumbai-based Compuware (India), a company that offers business software such as payroll processing solutions to customers.
“We have just learnt about the infringement of our trademark and our legal arm at the US office is looking at it to see how best it can be resolved. We have to see if it requires a legal notice or any other mechanism,” said Raaj N. Shinde, vice-president, international operations of Compuware.
Shinde added the company would take all steps to protect its internationally recognized brand. Compuware has not yet written to the Indian firm about the violation. The founder and head of the Mumbai-based firm, Sunil Merchant, said his firm is not aware of the existence of the US company. “Compuware is a generic name. There are a dozen other companies having the same brand name as Compuware in some form or the other. As long as their (business) domains are different from us, we have no problem with that,” he added. The problem facing Compuware is one other multinationals have addressed before it.
Wal-Mart Stores Inc. was fighting 11 cases in Indian trademark offices to stop the use of names similar to its own. In 2006, it dragged a local dealer for Samsung Electronics Co. to court. The dealer’s lawyer, Pragyan Sharma, said in February that his client was filing for a settlement and would no longer use the Wal-Mart name. Wal-Mart’s lawyer Sharad Vadehra said at the time that his client had already registered around a hundred trademarks in India.

Legal experts say the Mumbai firm in this case could attract action for infringing a registered trademark of an international company. Compuware has registered its trademark in the US.
Under Indian laws, trademark protection applies to words, names, symbols, or devices that distinguish the owner’s goods from those of others. If the trademark is registered, legal action could be initiated against infringement. In the case of unregistered marks, the only protection is the common law remedy of “passing off”.